With the advent of Instant Replay and Slow-Motion Camera technology, Major League Baseball is at a turning point.  Fans, umpires, and front offices have unprecedented access to information regarding what’s happening on the field, and with that information come some very pointed questions.  It doesn’t do much good to have every camera angle if the rules aren’t clearly defined.

What follows is a list of things that I think the MLB needs to define clearly within the rules in the future in order for Instant Replay to work the way it is intended.  Without these clarifications, the rules will remain shrouded under a cloud of mystery to the average fan, causing much frustration.  Statistics for this are courtesy of the excellent Baseball Savant.

1) Which parts of the uniform are relevant for tag plays?  Tag Plays in 2015 are over 40% of challenges, so this one is huge.  The idea of a tag is rather nebulous when you break it down.  Here’s what the official MLB rules say:

(c) He is tagged, when the ball is alive, while off his base.

Well, that doesn’t help us much.  The colloquial idea of a tag is that a hand holding the ball, or a glove holding the ball, or even the ball itself while it is held by a glove, must touch the runner while maintaining possession of the ball.  Here are a few examples where this gets dicey:

  • The fielder’s hand only gets the loose part of the uniform, and not the body (AKA the playground debate).
  • The strings hanging off the fielder’s glove touch the runner during a slide (the N*SYNC debate)
  • The fielder tags a runner’s hair during a tag (the Troy Polamalu debate)

You get the idea.  It’d be preferable if MLB could clear this up before it becomes a rather silly debate/awkward conversation in the replay room.

2) When does a First Baseman have possession?  This comes up at least once a week for every team; the play at first has made up nearly 35% of all challenge plays this year.  On a bang-bang play at first base, there are often moments when it seems that the runner hits the bag at the same time that the ball hits the glove.  I’ve heard it said colloquially that the out is recorded when the ball hits the back of the glove, but this does seem a bit ambiguous.  For instance, if an outfielder has a ball hit the back of his glove, but then the ball pops out when he’s rolling on the ground, it’s not a catch.  I’ve always thought that, sort of like in the NFL, some sort of baseball move has to happen for possession to be established.  If we establish a clear precedent in writing, perhaps that for first basemen only “Ball Hits Web” is equal to possession, then replays would be more clear and would take less time.

3) What is “one play” for review purposes?  Let’s take a look at an example of this from a recent A’s game:

In this play, the runner is originally ruled safe on the original slide, and ruled out on the overslide.  Upon review, the runner was called out on the original slide.  The question at play here is “Is this one play with two calls, or is this one play?”  The rules give examples of a catch call leading to a tag play as two separate plays, but two calls on the same play at the bag are not mentioned.  Having more examples here would clear this up.

4) What is an appropriate running lane? Rule 7.08 (b)-1 says that the appropriate running lane is 3 feet on either side of the path, but this isn’t enforced thoroughly.  This could easily be done; make all the basepaths easily defined on the paths, or have a Pitch F/X type system that superimposes the running lane onto the replay screen.  Without this, there will always be arguments about the width of the basepath.

5) What exactly is a swing?  The rules are woefully inadequate here.  The rules hint at such terms as “strikes at the ball” but this is literally up to anyone’s interpretation.  Everybody has their own interpretation; wrists breaking, bat crossing the plane, etc.  We’re going to get eventually to the point where replay technology is fast enough to review swing calls, and there has to be a precise definition before this can happen.

6) What is and isn’t a balk?  We’ve all seen days when a lefty pitcher gets called for three balks by Bob Davidson, and protesting that he’s been doing the same move the whole season.  That pitcher has a point.  The rules have regulations regarding balks, and they’re pretty clearly laid out, but they’re not enforced uniformly.  After we get some consistency with enforcement, we can move this into a more fan-friendly understanding.

There are a lot of other ambiguities that could be discussed here (Where is the Strike Zone?  Is the Neighborhood Play allowed? etc.) but these are just some ideas for what MLB could clear up in order to save themselves some headaches.  As we delve further down the replay rabbit hole, we need the rules to be clarified just as much as we need our viewpoint clarified.

Next post:
Previous post:

One Response to “Instant Replay: Clearly Unclear”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *